Trattoria di Carlo: Authentic Italian Dining Experience in Oak Creek

The staff was very friendly. The place looks amazing. Beautiful unique decor. The prices are great for the nice size portions. Then the food was absolutely amazing. We had a veggie pizza, fettuccine alfredo, Sicilian salad, chocolate cake, and cheesecake. We took manicotti to go. Everyone loved the food and were full.

I had my Mom's surprise birthday party here and they did a great job! The food was great and we had a private room for our event. Everyone loved the pizza! Frank, the owner even helped us pull off the big surprise. They were easy to work with and had great communication. Thank you so much for helping us plan this special event. It meant a lot to my family and me.

We recently held a celebration of life for my mom in the private back dining room, and I cannot recommend this venue highly enough. Planning an event during such a difficult time can be overwhelming, but Frank provided invaluable guidance. He helped us curate a perfect limited menu that included a wonderful selection of appetizers, diverse entree options, a great wine list, and delicious desserts. The food was outstanding and so was the service. Everything was truly great.

Got a 14 inch pizza a couple weeks ago. It was good but the toppings did not go to the edge of the crust, essentially turning it into a 12 inch pizza.

The food was awesome! We had a group of 8 and everything was really great. The service was excellent, the atmosphere inviting and food came out timely. The owners were on site and stopped by to check on us. We will definately be back again and tell our friends about this restaurant.

Trattoria di Carlo came to the rescue in hosting our wedding rehearsal dinner when no other resturant within the area would on a Friday night- even giving 2 months notice and willing to pay a deposit! Frank was fantastic with communication and providing flexibility with their menu options, and even gave us tips on how to save money with drink and bottle options for our large group of 30+ guests. We were provided our own room and staff, which Sarah, our waitress, was an absolute machine taking care of us. The food was absolutely delicious and our guests wouldnt stop raving about how wonderful the food and experience was. My wife and I genuinely felt taken care of here and wouldn't hesitate to book here again!

This is one of my Mom's favorite restaurants and now I know why! There was not a bad part of this visit. The servers were attentive and the food was fantastic! I love the look of the restaurant and every dish was as good as it looked! I understand that you might be too full to eat dessert after such a delicious meal BUT, they will happily pack your dessert "to go" ! No excuses not to enjoy one of their desserts! If you want a large family meal or a nice dinner for 2, this is your place! Stop in and enjoy!

DiCarlos never disappoints! We went on a Friday evening and were seated right away. They have such a delicious menu, and your choices are deliciously endless. We had a wonderful server who did an excellent job. We ordered garden salad, ceasar salad, cheese curds, garlic bread with marinara sauce, shrimp Alfredo and a cheese, sausage and pepperoni pizza. Everything tasted amazing! You will never go wrong choosing this restaurant.